Review Did you have a preference for one?
Was it a, b, c, d, e or f?
Does this surprise you or not?
Learn Now here are some of the things which have been said about
each type (
Biggs JB (1987), Student Approaches to Learning and Study, Melbourne: Australian Council for
Educational Research
)
a
People with a preference for type ‘a’
intend to meet the requirements which teachers put in front of them, but to do it just
well enough to get by. These learners strike a balance between working too hard and
failing. They think of their learning in terms of what they can get from it.
B
People with a preference for type ‘b’
study because they are interested, and because they want to get better at something,
maybe some subjects. They learn because they are interested in it for its own sake.
C
People with a preference for type ‘c’
study because they want to come top and/or be seen as the best. These learners work
to get the highest grades, whether or not what they are learning is interesting.
D
People with a preference for type ‘d’
study in a way which helps them reproduce what they have learned. They limit
themselves to parts which are absolutely necessary, and memorise these so that they
can repeat them.
e
People with a preference for type ‘e’
study in a way which concentrates on the meaning of what they are learning. They
read around the subject, and want to connect what they are learning with things they
have learned before.
f
People with a preference for type ‘f’
study in a way which gives attention to how they organise their time, their working
space, and so on. They make sure they get things done, and behave like a ‘model
pupil’.
• People with a preference for a or d focus on surface things and do well with
those, but not so well when the learning gets more complex.
• People with a preference for b or e focus on the meaning or understandings
and do better when they find learning is more complex.
• People with a preference for c or f focus on how to achieve,and get on pretty
well at the sort of learning valued by schools.
Apply
Think about some learning that you want to do soon.Would one of the preferences
above be best for that learning? Can you practise using that strategy and see how it goes?
Talk over the detail of what you will try with a friend.
57
LEARNING STYLES QUESTIONNAIRE
This questionnaire is designed to find out your preferred learning styles.1
There is no time limit. It will probably take you 10–15 minutes.
If you mostly agree with a statement put a tick by it.
1
I like to be absolutely correct about things
T
2
I quite like taking risks
A
3
I prefer solving problems step-by-step, rather than guessing
T
4
I prefer simple straightforward things to something complicated
P
5
I often do things ‘just because I like it’ rather than thinking about them
first
A
6
I don’t often take things for granted. I like to check things for myself
T
7
The most important thing about what you learn is if it works in practice
P
8
I’m always looking for new things to do
A
9
When I hear a new idea, I immediately start thinking how I can work it
out
P
10
I am keen on fixed routines and timetables
T
11
I take great care to work things out. I don’t like jumping to conclusions
R
12
I make decisions very carefully. I look at all the possibilities first
R
13
I don’t like ‘loose ends’. I prefer things to fit into a kind of pattern
T
14
I get straight to the point in discussions
P
15
I like the challenge of new and different things
A
16
I prefer thinking things through before coming to a conclusion
R
17
I don’t find it easy to think of wild ideas off the top of my head
T
18
I love lots of information – the more I have to sift through the better
R
19
I prefer jumping in and doing things to planning in advance
A
20
I tend to judge other people’s ideas on how well they will work in
practice
P
21
You can’t make a decision just because it feels right. You have to think
about all the facts
R
22
I’m fussy about how I do things – a bit of a perfectionist
T
23
I usually come up with lots of unusual ideas in discussions
A
24
In discussions I only put forward ideas that I know will work
P
25
I look at problems from as many angles as possible before starting to
solve them
R
26
Usually I talk more than I listen
A
27
Quite often I work out more practical ways of doing things
P
28
I believe that careful logical thinking is the key to getting things done
T
29
If I’m writing a formal letter, I try out several rough drafts first
R
30
I like to consider all my options before making up my mind
R
31
I don’t like creative ideas.They aren’t very practical
P
32
It’s best to look before you leap
R
33
I usually do more listening than talking
R
34
I can’t be bothered with rules and plans
P
35
It doesn’t matter how you do something so long as it works
A
36
I’m usually the life and soul of the party
A
37
I do whatever I need to do get the job done
P
38
I like to find out how things work
T
39
I like meetings or discussions to follow a pattern and timetable
T
40
I don’t mind in the least if things get out of hand
A
58
Add up the number of ticks for each letter.
Put the scores for each letter in the boxes below
A R
T
P
Activist Reflector
Theorist
Pragmatist
You will probably find that you are a mixture of two or three learning styles. If
you have high scores in two styles, you are probably happy with both these ways
of learning. If your score is fairly evenly spread, you are probably happy with learning
in several ways.
Review Is the result similar to or different from what you might have expected?
Learn How does your profile of styles look? Did you have a strong preference for one style? For
more than
one?
Now read the characteristics which are suggested for each style.
• Activists tend to be open-minded and enthusiastic about new things. They will try anything
once and like to tackle problems by brainstorming. They are usually outgoing and like to be the
centre of attention. They are well
suited to working in projects, learning in groups and bouncing ideas off others. They may enjoy
role-playing but may find they need help concentrating on lectures, writing up projects and
analysing research.
• Reflectors like to stand back and think before they act. They are usually quiet; they like to look
at the big picture on any topic and are very ordered and thorough. They are keen on listening to
experts and doing background reading. They get a kick out of doing and using their own
research, but are
unlikely to be at their best when presenting ideas to a group.
• Theorists are analytical and love detail. They are hardworking perfectionists. They are the ones
who take a logical structured approach and are quick at pulling together odd bits of information.
They like lectures with plenty of theory and gathering views and opinions. Writing up notes and
doing analytical exercises is their thing. They do not react well to uncertainty or people being
flippant about serious issues.
• Pragmatists are very down-to-earth and keen to see if theories work in practice. They see
problems as a challenge and they are always sure there is a better way to do things. They enjoy
being shown ‘how to’ more than practising themselves. They are more tuned in to presenting
ideas in smaller groups, writing up projects and using research data. They are weaker on tackling
abstract ideas and background reading.
Review Identify occasions when you have adopted the style of an activist, a reflector, a theorist,
and a pragmatist.
Learn Can you identify both strengths and weaknesses for your preferred style? And for your
less preferred style? Do your preferences for learning activities reflect your styles? Most learning
needs all four of the preferences at some time or other.
Apply Are there some of these which you wish to develop more? If so, how will you go about it
and who can help?
This instrument is based around the Honey and Mumford approach to learning styles, and is intended to give you a
flavour of that approach. For a fuller look, please refer to the manual: Honey P and Mumford A (1992), The
Manual of Learning Styles, revised edition, obtainable from Peter Honey, Maidenhead SL6 6HB
59
BELIEFS ABOUT SUCCESS
This activity can help you to look at your beliefs about succeeding.1 Different people have
different beliefs: sometimes they can help us succeed, sometimes they can hinder.
Do For each of the 16 statements, mark whether you agree or disagree with them. There is space
for you to note down your other thoughts as you go through.
Agree
Disagree
Other
thoughts
1
Sensible planning is a key factor in success
2
Pupils who do well in examinations usually
get a lot of help from parents
3
Teachers only praise you to make you work
harder
4
When you fail it is usually because you
did not work hard enough
5
A regular study pattern usually leads to
good results
6
I need grades on the last test before I
can plan what to work on next
7
When I get things wrong it’s because the
teacher didn’t explain clearly
8
If you’re told you aren’t ‘able’ there’s
no point trying
9
Doing well in exams is largely a matter
of luck
10
At my age it’s difficult to study because
you have to go out with your friends
11
I usually seem to do badly when I have
to compete with others
12
People complain the exam was unfair
when they didn’t prepare for it
13
There’s no point to school if you can’t
get a job
14
Progress in a subject depends on
whether you like the teacher
15
You can learn how to do better next
time from your mistakes
16
It’s who you know that’s important
for success in life
Review Discuss your responses with colleagues in small groups. Look for similarities and
differences between you.
Learn Which beliefs can hinder you? What do you blame when you do not succeed? How does
this affect you? Which beliefs can help you? How can you use more of them?
Apply Try and notice the impact of beliefs and blaming on your learning. When this happens
what will you do differently? What do you know of examples that seem to work for you where
you have managed beliefs and blaming differently?
60
LEARNING SITUATIONS – IN SCHOOL
This activity can help you think in detail about the different learning situations you meet in
school. And it might help you to get more out of them!
Do Compare learning in school in the following situations:
• two situations in which you are learning well
• one situation where you are not learning well
• a learning situation in school when you are not in lessons.
For each of the situations, think about the questions in the table and make some notes.
Learning well
1
Learning well
2
Not learning well Learning not in
1 2 lesson
What situation
is it? Where?
Who are you
with?
Who is
organising
the situation?
Who sets
the agenda?
In what way
does the agenda
include your
goals?
How do you go
about the
learning?
How do you feel
about the
learning?
Review What differences do you notice between the situations? What similarities do you see in
the situations? Compare your answers with a friend’s. Are they similar or
different?
Learn Look at your notes and identify two or three ways in which the ‘learning well’ situations
are different from the ‘not learning well’ situations.
Apply Can you use any of what you know about good learning situations to help you improve
the not so good learning situation? Discuss this in a small group and decide what actions you
might take.
61
LEARNING SITUATIONS – BEYOND SCHOOL
This activity can help you think about learning as a lifelong process – in other words the idea
that learning does not stop after school! It can also help you in your skills of learning by doing
research.
Do Design an interview to find out experiences and views of other people about learning in and
out of school and after they left school, including learning in and out of the workplace.
What are they learning now? Where? Who with? And how is it similar to or different from the
learning they did
at school?
Use your interview to talk to a range of people, for example:
• someone who has just left school
• someone who has had more than one job
• someone who is not in paid work
• a retired person.
Review What happened? Did you have any surprises in what people said about learning?
What did it feel like asking these people?
Did you think your interview got the information you wanted?
If you did the activity ‘Learning – in school and out’, did what people said differ from what you
said in that activity?
Learn What did you learn from people’s responses:
• What and how people need in order to learn at different
times?
• How much learning people do after they leave school?
• How learning changes over time?
• Their view of learning?
What did you learn from this about doing research?
Apply What ideas are you having about your own learning after leaving school?
Redesign your interview to take account of what you have learned about doing this research.
You might want to extend this research to more people or to ask more questions.
62
FIST-TO-FIVE
Skills
Self-Management
What is it?
This simple activity encourages pupils to determine how confident they feel that they’ve
achieved what was expected by the end of a lesson or session. It might also be used by pupils as
a means of expressing how confident they are that they know the response to a question which
has just been posed by the teacher/facilitator. For the latter, this activity allows an instant
assessment of how well a class or group may have grasped an issue or topic. See Thumb Tool
for another activity which encourages pupils to think about their learning.
How does it work?
1. After a session pupils are asked how confident they are that they have met the objectives. One
of three hand gestures might be used: Full hand up with all fingers and thumb if they are very
confident that they have achieved the objectives and what was expected;
Three fingers if they feel that they have had partial success in meeting the objectives, but some
more work might be needed; or Just fist if they consider that they have made little or no progress
towards meeting the objective.
2. If the tool is being used in response to a specific question from the teacher during
the course of the lesson, the following statements might apply: Full hand up with all fingers and
thumb if they feel very confident that they know the answer; Three fingers if they may know part
of the answer or if they are slightly uncertain as to the accuracy of their response; or Just fist if
they definitely feel that they do not know the response.
3. If the tool is used at the end of a session, a debrief may explore issues such as how the
objective was met, what else pupils feel that they would like to achieve and how they could go
about doing this, what might have hindered progress towards the objective and how they can
prevent future similar obstacles.
63
KWL (Know – Want to Know – Learned)
Skills
Managing Information
Self-Management
What is it?
This method can be used as an introductory strategy in order for pupils to document
their present level of knowledge and what gaps may exist in that knowledge, to
structure progress in their learning and to analyse what new information has been
learned after research. This activity builds upon prior knowledge and understanding
and develops teamwork skills. If the K-W-L is carried out in groups, it may
consolidate communication skills and teamwork.
How does it work?
1. On a K-W-L grid (see below), pupils write under ‘K’ what they think they already
know about a particular topic or issue. If pupils are working in groups, they may
wish to use a Post-It style activity before writing their combined ideas onto the grid.
2. Pupils are then encouraged to think about the gaps in their knowledge by filling out
what they want to know in the ‘W’ column.
3. Once the topic is completed, pupils might return to their grids to fill in the final ‘L’
column. Here they confirm the accuracy of their first two columns and compare
what they have learned with their initial thoughts on the topic in the ‘K’ column.
Topic: Tanzania
K
W
L
developing country
Masai tribes
Mount Kilimanjaro
lack of health services
safari
about schools
imports/exports
cost of living
tribal life
other geographical
points of interest
tribal life based around
cattle herding and
warrior manship
Ngorongoro Crater
64
CRITICAL THINKING
Critical thinking is a disciplined approach to conceptualizing, evaluating, analyzing and
synthesizing information from observation, experience, refection or reasoning. It can then
become the basis for action. Critical thinking is often associated with a willingness to imagine or
remain open to considering alternative perspectives, to integrate new or revised perspectives into
our ways of thinking and acting, and with a commitment to participatory democracy and to
fostering criticality in others.
At a basic level, the process of critical thinking involves:
•
gathering relevant information;
•
evaluating and questioning evidence;
•
drawing warranted conclusions and generalizations;
•
revising assumptions and hypotheses on the basis of wider experience.
The following are the steps that children can be guided through and the skills they will
use in undertaking classroom activities:
1. Process the information derived from visual or from oral evidence. This could equally be
applied to information derived from reading primary source documents, data gathered from
a survey or questionnaire, or information collected from several secondary sources, such
as a selection of textbooks, encyclopedias or websites.
2. Understand key points, assumptions or hypotheses that structure investigation of the
evidence, or in later activities, underlie the arguments.
3. Analyse how these key components, and the visual and oral evidence, ft together and relate
to each other.
4. Compare and explore the similarities and differences between individual images, or
between different personal accounts and memories.
5. Synthesise by bringing together different sources of information to construct an argument or
set of ideas. Make connections between the different sources that shape and support your
ideas.
6. Evaluate the validity and reliability of evidence in relation to your investigation, and how
the evidence supports or contradicts your assumptions and emerging ideas.
7. Apply the understanding gained by presenting an interpretation in response to the
questions that underlay the investigation.
8. Justify ideas and interpretations in defending arguments about the conclusions reached
and implications identif
i
ed.
Bloom’s taxonomy of Education Goals has been one of the most influential books among
teachers, who want to develop pupil’s critical thinking in the process of active teaching and
learning.
|